General News

Supreme Court Ruling on Vacant Parliamentary Seats Sparks Constitutional Controversy

Amazon Store

Former Director of the Ghana School of Law, Kwaku Ansa-Asare, has strongly criticized the Supreme Court’s decision to grant a stay of execution on Speaker Alban Bagbin’s declaration of four parliamentary seats vacant. In an interview on TV3’s KeyPoints, Ansa-Asare argued that the court’s ruling has created room for “constitutional lawlessness”.

Ansa-Asare pointed out procedural lapses in the Supreme Court’s handling of the matter, noting that the court’s jurisdiction was not properly invoked since the Speaker and Attorney-General, key parties in the case, were not heard. He described the ruling as “amorphous and meaningless” and emphasized that serving the Speaker through the legal department was incorrect, as it should have been done personally or through the Clerk.

The controversy began when Speaker Bagbin declared four seats vacant after the occupants decided to contest the 2024 elections as Independent Candidates. However, Alexander Afenyo-Markin quickly filed an ex-parte motion at the Supreme Court, seeking a stay of execution of Bagbin’s ruling. The Apex Court granted the motion, directing the Speaker to allow the MPs to occupy their seats in Parliament.

Ansa-Asare condemned the Supreme Court’s actions, stating that they amounted to “provocation of Parliament” and “contempt of court.” He believes the court should have granted a ten-day stay of execution, rather than the indefinite stay granted.

As Parliament resumes on Tuesday, Ansa-Asare anticipates a “constitutional showdown.” This development has sparked concerns about the separation of powers and the potential for constitutional conflicts between the judiciary and legislature.

In a separate interview with JoyNews, Ansa-Asare maintained that Parliament’s decisions, including the Speaker’s declaration of vacant seats, are shielded from judicial review due to the principle of separation of powers. He emphasized that each arm of government operates within its own domain, and Parliament’s decisions should be respected.

The unfolding constitutional controversy highlights the complex relationships between Ghana’s institutions and the need for clarity on their respective roles and powers.

Ruth Abla ADJORLOLO